Our History
Holmdel Community United Church of Christ traces its roots back to the 1660s, making it one of the oldest congregations in Monmouth County. The church began as the First Baptist Society formed by early English settlers in the Holmdel area. In 1705, the congregation built its first meeting house in Holmdel Village. The original church was known as the Upper Meeting House of the Baptist Church in Middletown.  During the Revolutionary War, British soldiers reportedly occupied the church building during the Battle of Monmouth.
The church was rebuilt in 1809.  A large Victorian parsonage was added to the property in 1882. The chapel portion of the church was partially constructed in 1886. Major renovations in 1896 helped preserve the historic structure for future generations, particularly the 6 Tiffany-stained glass windows in the sanctuary.

The church later became affiliated with the United Church of Christ denomination. Today, the congregation combines historic traditions with progressive Christian values. In 2009, the church officially declared itself “Open and Affirming” to welcome LGBTQIA+ members. The church is known for its commitment to justice, peace, and community outreach programs. Its historic campus remains located at 40 Main Street in Holmdel, New Jersey. More than 350 years after its founding, the church continues to serve as both a spiritual and historical landmark in Holmdel.